Cleveland's Trade: A "Mid-Term" Report Card
One of the most interesting things that I discovered while doing the research for this article is that, despite all the talk about how much work LeBron James has done to improve his outside shooting and his free throw shooting, his three point percentage has declined for the third straight season and his free throw percentage is below his career average. He has had some games in which he shot very well from one or both of those areas but, as a rule, he is a streak shooter from both distances and the cold streaks last longer than the hot ones.Prior to tonight's game versus Detroit, Cleveland had played 14 games since trading away six players to acquire Ben Wallace, Joe Smith, Wally Szczerbiak and Delonte West and the Cavaliers had 14 games remaining before the end of the season. Therefore, now is the perfect time to issue a "mid-term" report card about the trade's impact on the Cavaliers (6/17/15 edit: the link to CavsNews.com no longer works, so I have posted the original article below):
As of March 18,
the Cleveland Cavaliers have played 14 games since acquiring Ben Wallace, Joe
Smith, Wally Szczerbiak and Delonte West in exchange for six players. There are
14 games left in the regular season, so now is a perfect time to issue a
“mid-term” report card about the trade’s impact on the Cavaliers. Obviously,
final grades will not be issued until the playoffs are over.
In the first
game after the trade, the Cavs were not able to use their new players but they
still managed to eke out a one point win over a Washington team that was without the
services of injured All-Stars Gilbert Arenas and Caron Butler. Since that time,
except for one missed game by Szczerbiak and one and a half missed games by
Wallace, the new Cavs have played in all 13 games. Cleveland went 7-6 in those games. Other than
a 92-87 road loss to the Boston Celtics, Cleveland
did not face any teams that would be considered legitimate championship
contenders; in fact, the majority of those games were against teams that will
not even make the playoffs. Clearly, being one game above .500 against that
kind of competition is hardly a ringing endorsement of the deal.
Of course,
there are a couple extenuating factors that must be considered. First, the
Cavaliers are basically conducting training camp on the fly as they integrate
the new players into their offensive and defensive systems and the new and
established Cavs get used to playing with each other. Second, injuries have
sidelined several key players, hurting the team’s depth and hindering efforts
to establish a regular rotation and get everyone settled into their roles.
Starting center Zydrunas Ilgauskas missed eight of these 13 games and the
Cavaliers only went 4-4 in his absence. Sharpshooter Daniel Gibson missed all
13 games. Sasha Pavlovic missed the first nine games.
Contrary to
popular belief, the presence or absence of players other than LeBron James has significantly
affected the Cavs’ performance at various times this season. The team clearly
struggled at the start of the season when Pavlovic and Anderson Varejao were
holding out. Also, in several of the games that the team lost when James did
not play other key players—notably Varejao and Larry Hughes—also were out of
action. James is by far the most important player but a close examination of
this season shows that the Cavs need to have most of their eight man rotation
intact in order to be successful, particularly against good teams.
Considering
that the team needs some time to adjust to the big trade and that injuries have
taken an important toll recently, one could say that the “mid-term” report card
should read “incomplete.” However, it is worth taking a closer look at the
individual performances of the new players in order to try to project what
their impact will be in the future. Before doing that, though, it is
interesting to consider what effect—if any--all of this change has had on
James’ production. He averaged 33.4 ppg, 7.6 rpg and 7.4 apg during the 13
games, shooting .487 from the field, .316 from three point range and .732 from
the free throw line. How do those numbers compare to his season-long
performance? His scoring is up significantly (more than 2 ppg), his free throw
percentage is up marginally, his assists and field goal percentage are
essentially unchanged and his rebounding is down slightly. There has been much
talk about how much work James has put into his shooting stroke but his three
point shooting percentage has declined for the third straight year and his free
throw percentage is below his career average. James remains a streak shooter
from both areas—and, unfortunately, the cold streaks last a lot longer than the
hot ones: he shot 7-13 from three point range in his 50 point game in New York
but he shot just 17-63 (.270) on three pointers in the other 12 games. Take out
his 5-8 performance against Indiana and the numbers not only drop to 12-55
(.218) but he shot less than .300 from three point range in each of the other
11 games. His free throw shooting is not nearly as bad but is similarly
inconsistent, ranging from back to back 11-12 outings to games in which he shot
2-5, 10-16 and 16-23.
Cleveland’s offense is heavily dependent on
James’ ability to drive to the hoop and finish with authority combined with his
great passing skills. The hope that Szczerbiak would relieve some pressure from
James by making outside shots has not yet been realized. Szczerbiak is
averaging just 9.2 ppg with the Cavs while shooting .313 from the field and
.349 from three point range. He has not lost his shooting touch—as shown by the
fact that he has made 23 of 24 free throws—but as a Cav he has not shown the
ability to consistently make open jumpers in game situations. Even more
worrisome, his recent numbers read like a countdown to oblivion: 31, 13, 10 and
six minutes played resulting in seven, six, three and two points scored. His
defense has never been great, so Szczerbiak seems to be playing himself right
out of the rotation. Some publicity seeking wiseguys created a website specifically
devoted to imploring Larry Hughes not to shoot, so it is worth mentioning that
since the trade Hughes has averaged 15.3 ppg for the Bulls while shooting .406
from the field and .359 from three point range. He is playing more than 33 mpg
and it should go without saying that his defense is much better than
Szczerbiak’s.
Delonte West
is probably the newcomer who has made the smoothest transition. Coach Mike
Brown immediately installed him as the starting point guard and he has averaged
9.9 ppg, 4.2 apg and 3.9 rpg. He has already had a 20 point game, he had eight
rebounds in another contest and he has posted seven assists twice. On the other
hand, his field goal percentage (.426) is below his career average and even
though he can help the Cavs at times in terms of pushing the ball up the court
he has never been the type of player who can consistently get into the paint
and draw fouls; West has attempted only 19 free throws in 13 games as a Cav and
in six of those games he did not get to the free throw line even once.
Drew Gooden
played an important role in Cleveland’s
success, so Ben Wallace must be productive for the trade to be considered a
success. So far, the best that can be said is that the results have been mixed.
Back spasms caused Wallace to miss the second half of the Portland game and all of the next game versus
the Nets. Perhaps they have limited him in other games as well; he has averaged
5.4 ppg, 8.3 rpg and 1.4 bpg as a Cav. Wallace has reached double figures in
rebounding just three times as a Cav. His offensive limitations are well
documented and—although I believe that he can be productive offensively as long
as he sets screens, crashes the boards and finishes around the hoop—the fact
that no one on the roster has emerged as a dependable scorer to complement
James and Ilgauskas is worrisome and puts more pressure on Wallace to provide
something at that end of the court. Gooden rebounded just as well as Wallace does
and he is a much better shooter and scorer.
Joe Smith has
been solid, if unspectacular, averaging 8.5 ppg and 6.1 rpg while shooting .487
from the field and .658 from the free throw line. He can step out and make the
midrange jumper and he is rebounding well for the amount of minutes that he
plays. Smith does not have three point range like Donyell Marshall but it is
fair to say that this exchange was without question an upgrade for the Cavs.
Before the
Cavs made this trade I asked Is the Status Quo Really So Bad for the Cavs? I argued that the Cavs should not break up the
team that made it to the Finals unless they could make a deal that
significantly improved the team’s chances to win in the playoffs. It is still
possible that the positives of this trade—more frontcourt depth, Szczerbiak’s
outside shooting, West’s ability to play point guard—will outweigh the
negatives—questions about how much Wallace has left in the tank, Szczerbiak’s
defense, whether or not the overall production of the “new” team in the
playoffs will really match what the “old” team did last year--but so far the
Cavaliers do not look like a better team now than they did either last season
or even this season when the roster was completely intact. That said, it must
be emphasized that this trade cannot be fairly and completely evaluated until
all of the key players are healthy and we see how the team performs in the
playoffs; if the Cavs get healthy, rededicate themselves to playing good
defense on a nightly basis and get solid offensive production from someone
other than James and Ilgauskas then they will still be a formidable playoff
team.
Labels: Ben Wallace, Cleveland Cavaliers, Delonte West, Joe Smith, LeBron James, Wally Szczerbiak
posted by David Friedman @ 3:40 PM
0 Comments:
Post a Comment
<< Home