20 Second Timeout

Knicks Outplay and Outcoach Cavaliers to Take 2-0 Eastern Conference Finals Lead

After trailing the Atlanta Hawks 2-1 in the first round, the New York Knicks have apparently morphed into some combination of Bill Russell's Boston Celtics, the Kareem Abdul-Jabbar-Magic Johnson L.A. Lakers, the Michael Jordan-Scottie Pippen Chicago Bulls, the Shaquille O'Neal-Kobe Bryant L.A. Lakers, and the Kevin Durant-Stephen Curry Golden State Warriors. I am not suggesting that the Knicks are as good as any of those fabled championship teams, nor am I even predicting that the Knicks will win the 2026 NBA championship--but it is worth noting that the Knicks have already accomplished things that none of those teams accomplished, including posting the best point differential in a 10 game span in NBA playoff history, winning three consecutive playoff games by at least 25 points, opening a series with a 35-plus point win after ending a series with a 35-plus point win, and building a 47 point halftime lead in a playoff game. 

The Knicks may not be one of the greatest teams of all-time, but their statistical profile matches or even exceeds the statistical profiles of many dominant championship teams. The Knicks own a nine game playoff winning streak, and have a 2-0 Eastern Conference Finals lead over the Cleveland Cavaliers as that series shifts to Cleveland for games three and four. The Knicks led game one 23-16 at the end of the first quarter but then they did not just hit cruise control--they hit snooze control, falling into a 93-71 hole with 7:52 remaining in the fourth quarter. What happened next is one of the greatest comebacks (or greatest collapses, depending on your perspective) in NBA playoff history, as the Knicks outscored the Cavaliers 44-11 the rest of the way en route to a 115-104 overtime win. 

The Knicks turned things around with a brutally direct offensive tactic: Jalen Brunson attacked James Harden one on one, and if the Cavaliers had a different primary defender on Brunson then the Knicks used whoever Harden was guarding as a screener to force a switch putting Harden on Brunson. Brunson scored 15 fourth quarter points on 7-9 field goal shooting, and he finished with a game-high 38 points on 15-29 field goal shooting. We have seen many playoff duels featuring two players trading baskets, but it is unusual to see a player touted as one of the greatest guards ever being torched one on one this way. Harden had 15 points on 5-16 field goal shooting along with three assists and a team-high six turnovers, yet another "Harden" game; media members have apparently only recently noticed that Harden's playoff trademark is to have more turnovers than field goals made, but I pointed this out three years ago. Donovan Mitchell led the Cavaliers with 29 points, but Harden's atrocious defense meant that the Cavaliers were often taking the ball out of the net and playing against the Knicks' set defense as opposed to attacking in transition after rebounds or steals. Harden dominating the ball on offense and getting torched on defense is wonderful for the Knicks and horrible for the Cavaliers, which brings us to the topic of coaching.

New York coach Mike Brown is often maligned, but he is coaching circles around Cleveland's Kenny Atkinson in this series. Brown's defense is making it tough for Cleveland to score, and his offense is exploiting the Cavaliers' defensive weaknesses (mainly Harden). Atkinson was oddly reticent to call a timeout during Cleveland's game one collapse, and his postgame remarks suggested that he is detached from reality, contractually obligated to never criticize Harden, or both. Atkinson kept a straight face while insisting that Harden has been one of Cleveland's best defensive players, and he implausibly suggested that the Cavaliers had played well for three quarters before running into some bad luck late in the game because Brunson hit tough shots. The reality is that Harden has been a traffic cone as a perimeter defender throughout his career (he defends OK in the post, but that is of minimal value for a point guard who is guarding perimeter players), and the Knicks outplayed the Cavalier both early in the game and down the stretch. The Cavaliers maybe had about 15-20 minutes of good basketball, but Atkinson fiddled while Rome burned in the closing moments, and the result had nothing to do with luck.

Naturally, many media members said that the Cavaliers could not recover from losing game one, apparently forgetting that the Cavaliers bounced back from a 2-0 deficit in the previous series to beat Detroit in seven games; the question is not whether the Cavaliers are resilient, but whether the Cavaliers have matchup advantages that will enable them to beat New York four times.  

The Cavaliers took a 13-7 first quarter lead in game two, but the Knicks led 53-49 at halftime, never trailed in the second half, and were up by as much as 19 points before winning, 109-93. The Cavaliers finally stopped letting Brunson torture Harden one on one, but after they trapped Harden they had no effective response to Brunson's passing. Brunson finished with 19 points plus a playoff career-high 14 assists. Many of Brunson's assists went to Josh Hart, who scored a game-high tying 26 points. The Knicks shot .518 from the field, and each starter scored at least 14 points. Brown had been using Karl-Anthony Towns as a point center, but the Cavaliers' defense against Brunson turned Brunson into the primary playmaker, with Hart adding seven assists as well. Towns had 18 points, a game-high 13 rebounds, and just one assist; those numbers do not mean that Brown "forgot" about Towns or "doesn't know how to use Towns," but rather that the Knicks exploited the gaping holes in Cleveland's defense in other very effective ways.

Mitchell led the Cavaliers with 26 points, but Harden shot just 6-15 from the field to accumulate 18 points. Harden had no turnovers but also just two assists; the Cavaliers are smart to get the ball out of his hands as much as possible to limit his turnovers, but his inefficient shooting and leaky defense led to a game-worst -22 plus/minus number. The bottom line is that Harden is a defensive liability, and he cannot be hidden in the playoffs versus a good team that is well-coached. Evan Mobley had 14 first half points on 5-8 field goal shooting, but Atkinson, Mitchell, and Harden held Mobley to zero second half points on zero second half field goal attempts.

The Cavaliers are 8-8 in the 2026 playoffs, including 6-1 at home and 2-7 on the road, so I would not be surprised if the Cavaliers win at least one game versus the Knicks in Cleveland, and I will not fall into the common trap of being swayed by what happens from game to game; it is hilarious to listen to people who don't understand basketball--or who are trying to gain attention with hot takes--make outlandish proclamations on the basis of one game. No matter what happened in the previous game, the next game starts 0-0 with a different officiating crew and different circumstances. Playoff basketball is about matchups, and matchup advantages do not change (unless a player gets injured, or is disqualified via fouls or ejection); over the course of a series, I expect the team with the most matchup advantages to prevail, and that is why I expect the Knicks to win this series even though the sweep talk is premature. I picked the Knicks to win in six games, and that still seems reasonable, pending what happens in game three. Harden often has one or two decent games before his final choke of the series, and if he does not collapse in game three then the Cavaliers may hit enough shots to win.

Labels: Cleveland Cavaliers, Donovan Mitchell, Evan Mobley, Jalen Brunson, James Harden, Josh Hart, Karl-Anthony Towns, New York Knicks

posted by David Friedman @ 3:24 PM

0 comments