What Happened to Dave Berri?
Dave Berri is a name that I have not thought about in quite some time. More than a decade ago, I wrote a few articles debunking his flawed and tendentious NBA analysis; he declared, among other things, that Allen Iverson was a barely above average NBA player, that Dennis Rodman was more productive on a per minute basis than Michael Jordan, and that Andrew Bynum was more valuable to the Lakers than Kobe Bryant.
Later, during the 2011 NBA lockout, Berri--who is an economist by training--incorrectly asserted that the NBA's owners behave like socialists and he displayed a lack of understanding of how a sports league functions; in contrast, I correctly predicted that the lockout would be long, and I correctly anticipated the broad parameters of the new Collective Bargaining Agreement: the second longest work stoppage in league history did not end until, as I put it, "the players finally accepted the reality that the NBA's broken business model had to be fundamentally changed." Up to that point, the players had been receiving nearly 60% of the league's revenues even though many teams were losing money; once the players realized that such an arrangement is not feasible in the long run, the owners and players agreed to terms.
After Henry Abbott disappeared from ESPN--thus depriving Berri of one of his main media promoters--Berri's name came up much less often. Berri stopped posting at his main blog in 2011, he then started a new blog, and he stopped posting at the new blog in late 2015. Apparently, he got a gig as a writer for Forbes, but that proved to be short-lived, and I somehow missed the news of how his tenure there ended in disgrace in 2018: Forbes cuts ties with sports business columnist, deletes piece about WNBA player salaries.
Forbes' editors explained the decision to fire Berri by stating that the final article Berri submitted to Forbes was "misleading," "sloppy," "polemic," and "just bad reporting." Forbes also released this statement: "The
article was removed because it failed to meet Forbes' strict editorial
standards for accuracy and fairness. Specifically, the contributor intentionally omitted facts
and context from an authoritative source that would have undermined his
thesis. As a result, David Berri was removed as a Forbes contributor."
This does not surprise me, because I have firsthand experience with Berri engaging in similar behavior.
In Why Would LeBron James Become Captain of the Gotham Titanic? I wrote:
Last year, many Knicks' fans--and even some national commentators--were
thrilled at the prospect that D'Antoni and his fabled "seven seconds or
less" offensive system would improve the Knicks so much that LeBron
James could be the final piece that would make the Knicks a championship
contender. However, by the latter portion of the season, I pointed out that D'Antoni's Knicks were clearly heading in the wrong direction;
they were lousy defensively and on the boards and--most ominously--both
of those trends steadily worsened throughout the season. Despite all of
the buzz about D'Antoni, his Knicks finished 32-50 in 2008-09, one game
worse than the Knicks finished in Thomas' first season as their coach
(2006-07).
After I told the truth about the Knicks' plight,
diehard Knicks fan Mike Kurylo wrote a barely comprehensible screed in
response, misspelling my name and betraying complete ignorance not only
about NBA basketball but also about basic journalistic methods (he
suggested that I spelled out "fourth" instead of writing "4th" because
of some diabolical psychological plot to "visually" mislead readers when
the reality is that it is standard practice to spell out ordinal
numbers less than 10th). I refuted Kurylo's nonsense,
concluding "Mike K. declares that I 'cherry picked' numbers in a
'dishonest' attempt to tell a biased story but the reality is that I
simply cited the relevant numbers regarding the 2007, 2008 and 2009
Knicks, indicated that the D'Antoni Knicks have yet to surpass the level
that the Thomas Knicks reached in 2007 and suggested that the Knicks
need to make personnel and philosophical changes in order to become a
good team."
"Stat guru" Dave Berri also jumped into the mix,
incorrectly suggesting that my article compared the 2009 Knicks to the
2005 Knicks--a lie that distorts the meaning of what I wrote and that
Berri refuses to retract--and offering up his usual numbers-based rhetoric to suggest that the Knicks are in fact moving in the right direction.
I posted a comment on Berri's now-discontinued website asking him to correct his mischaracterization of what I wrote, but he never issued a correction or retraction.
Here is the conclusion of my analysis of the 2009 Knicks: "How will the Knicks be able
to justify to their fans the suffering of the 2009 and 2010 seasons if
the Knicks do not sign an elite player in the summer of 2010? Moreover,
even if the Knicks bring in an elite player they still would struggle to
win more than 45 games without doing a major restructuring of the rest
of their roster and a complete overhaul of their all-offense,
no-defense/rebounding philosophy."
After I asserted that the Knicks were not improving and would not be able to sign a top tier free agent, the Knicks went 29-53 in 2009-10. The Knicks failed in their attempt to lure LeBron James to come to New York and instead signed injury-prone free agent Amare Stoudemire, who was only healthy and productive in the first of his five seasons with the Knicks. The Knicks went 42-40 in 2010-11 before losing in the first round of the playoffs. D'Antoni resigned after the Knicks started 18-24 in 2011-12.
Bottom line:
(1) I was correct that the Knicks were not headed in the right direction under D'Antoni, and I was right that the Knicks were foolish if they thought that LeBron James was going to become captain of the Gotham Titanic.
(2) Media assertions/hopes that D'Antoni would turn the Knicks around were wrong; Berri misrepresented what I wrote, and then he agreed with incorrect analysis about the team's prospects while rejecting the analysis that I provided that proved to be correct.
Labels: "advanced basketball statistics", 2011 NBA lockout, Dave Berri, Forbes, journalism, New York Knicks
posted by David Friedman @ 3:47 AM


Marcellus Wiley Explains to Draymond Green the Difference Between "Different Realities" and "Double Standards"
I was going to refute the flawed thinking underlying Draymond Green's recent rant about "double standards" before I realized that Marcellus Wiley--a Columbia University graduate and a retired 10 year NFL veteran who earned Pro Bowl and All-Pro honors in 2001--had already done a brilliant and detailed analysis about why he disagrees with Draymond Green's assertion about alleged double standards in the NBA.
In case you missed it, Green is outraged because the Cleveland Cavaliers are not playing Andre Drummond while they decide whether to trade Drummond or to buy out his contract. Green ranted that there is a double standard permitting owners to force players to not play while James Harden was criticized for demanding to be traded by the Houston Rockets.
One important point that both Green and Wiley did not mention is that Harden did not merely ask to be traded; he openly quit on his team, and then he compounded matters by publicly saying that the talent surrounding him is not very good. So, Green's analogy failed to take into account the vast difference between an employee on a guaranteed contract not giving maximum effort and also undermining workplace morale versus an employer deciding that based on the best interests of all involved parties a particular employee should, in essence, be given a paid leave of absence.
The entire segment featuring Wiley is worth watching; here are some excerpts:
Emmanuel Acho begins the segment by asking Wiley, "Is there a double standard between teams and their star players?"
Wiley replies, "No, there is not a double standard." Wiley explains that this is not just an NBA issue or a sports issue but "a life issue." Wiley continues, "What's happening is Draymond is confusing what a lot of people are confusing: double standard with different worlds...Double standard implies that you're in the same world...I understand why people get confused, but the truth is we're in two different realities. Ask Michael Jordan, who is an owner. We [pro athletes] are employees, brother. I know we are glorified employees...[80,000] people showed up to just watch me work and not 80,000 people showed up at everybody's job/employment. But what happens from that perspective is you start to get a God complex. You start to lose your way. You start to realize that maybe I am not the same as other employees. Draymond Green and others need some real world friends to understand perspective. Because, when you are an employee there are two names on your check: yours, and whoever is paying you. You guys don't live in the same reality. It's just that simple. So, if you don't like bosses, be a boss--simple as that. Oh, you can't be a boss. Well, then, being a boss comes with its perks, comes with its privileges." Wiley then points out that salaries in the major sports leagues--the NBA, the NFL, MLB--have soared in the past decade, far outpacing inflation. He correctly notes that this is a major way that owners show respect to employees. He asks players like Green who claim to be disrespected, "What are your measurements? What are your metrics? This metric right here is undeniable. They are showing you respect."
Emmanuel Acho argues that the double standard consists of how fans perceive and react to players, and also how NFL contracts are "binding" on the players but are not guaranteed if the players gets cut. Regarding Acho's first point, fans have all kinds of opinions and standards--some fair, some not fair--but Green's point is that if owners are allowed to tell players to not play then players should also be able to not play--and, Wiley is correct that Green misunderstands the different reality between owning a business and being an employee of that business. Acho also misunderstands those different realities.
Regarding NFL contracts, they are different than NBA contracts because the only NFL money that is guaranteed for a player is the signing bonus, while most NBA contracts are fully guaranteed. However, Acho is wrong to call this a double standard. The correct phrase is "terms of employment." As Wiley said, if you don't like being an employee then be a boss: build a business from the ground up, or buy an existing business and run it however you want to run it. Wiley perceptively notes that Michael Jordan's perspective and public statements changed a lot after he made the transformation from employee to owner.
Wiley's intelligent analysis of the difference between being an owner and being an employee reminds me of my coverage of the 2011 NBA lockout, when I was almost the sole voice of reason. In one of my articles about the 2011 NBA lockout, I made a similar point about the difference between being an owner and being an employee, and I did so at a time when most media coverage betrayed an inability and/or unwillingness to understand the core issues, with Chris Sheridan incorrectly predicting that the lockout would end quickly, and Henry Abbott pretending that he better understands how to run an NBA franchise than NBA owners do. In contrast, I broke down the difference between being an owner and being an employee, and I correctly predicted, "No matter what Henry Abbott, the 'stat gurus' or Chris Sheridan say, the
lockout will continue until the players consent to a fundamental
restructuring of the NBA's business model--and the players have likely
passed up the best offer they will receive; subsequent offers will be
reduced by whatever amount of revenue the owners lose from cancelled
games, starting with the first two weeks of the regular season that
were officially wiped out just a few hours ago."
I had accurately predicted in February 2011 that there would be a long lockout in the fall of 2011, and by the time the owners and their employee players reached an agreement (along the lines of the agreement that I had predicted they would reach) the NBA experienced the second longest work stoppage in league history.
Accurate analysis is generally not popular, nor is it "clickbait," but I would prefer to understand the world as it is than live in a fantasy world devoid of reality and logic.
Labels: 2011 NBA lockout, Draymond Green, Marcellus Wiley, reality
posted by David Friedman @ 9:08 PM

